Idun Blue vs Memberful 4.9% of every payment or a fixed price
Memberful adds memberships to a site you already have, for $49 a month plus 4.9% of every payment. Idun Blue has a fixed monthly price, a 0% platform fee, and the site, courses, email and community in one account.
Our verdict
Memberful adds memberships and paywalls to a site you already have, especially WordPress. It runs on your own Stripe account, has no cap on members and charges $49 a month plus 4.9% of every successful charge, with Stripe's fees on top. Idun Blue charges a fixed price and 0% of your sales, and its website, courses, email, community and bookings are one system, so a purchase or a finished lesson can start the right email without an integration. Memberful is the cheaper of the two while member income stays below about $3,100 a month against Idun Blue's regular price, or about $1,000 against half price, and when you want to keep your WordPress site.
Sources (3) · checked 7 Oct 2026
Memberful pricing and plans were last checked on 7 Oct 2026 against Memberful’s own pages.
- Memberful's pricing page lists one Standard plan at $49 a month plus a 4.9% transaction fee, and a custom-priced Enterprise plan. Stripe's own processing fees come on top, and Memberful quotes them as typically 2.9% + $0.30.
- Memberful's tax help page says it helps collect applicable taxes at checkout but does not file or remit them. That stays with you.
- Memberful's pricing page does not state where data is hosted.
Feature by feature
| Feature | Idun Blue | Memberful |
|---|---|---|
| 0% platform fee | Included | Not included |
| WordPress plugin | Not included | Included |
| Free to set up until you take payments | Not included | Included |
| Both have | ||
| Payments to your own Stripe account | Included | Included |
| Tax calculated at checkout | Included | Included |
| Courses | Included | Included |
| Newsletters and podcasts | Included | Included |
| Community | Included | Included |
- Included
- Standout strength
- Included in Idun Blue, switched on in settings or in a simpler form
- Partial at Memberful, or a paid add-on
- Not included
A ◐ in Idun Blue never costs extra. The text below says whether you switch the feature on yourself or it comes in a simpler form. Rows where Memberful’s own pricing and help pages neither confirm nor deny a feature are left out, so a missing row doesn't mean Memberful lacks it.
What each is built for
Memberful handles billing and access for a membership, and is made to sit on top of a website you already run. In Idun Blue you build the website, the membership, the courses and the email in one account. Both run on your own Stripe account.
Memberful’s pricing
Memberful’s pricing page was checked on 7 October 2026:
- Standard: $49 a month plus 4.9% of every successful charge. Stripe’s processing fee comes on top, and Memberful says it is typically 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction.
- Enterprise: custom volume-based pricing.
- Free until you go live. You can build in test mode for as long as you like and are charged once you start taking payments.
The Standard plan includes subscriptions of any kind, free and paid trials, group plans, gift purchases, coupons, a referral programme, retention discounts, cancellation surveys, checkout in 15 languages, and support for podcasts, newsletters, communities, courses and downloads. There is no cap on members. Memberful requires a Stripe account and connects to WordPress, Mailchimp, Discord and Kit.
Do the maths
At $1,000 a month in member payments, Memberful costs $49 + $49 = $98 a month before Stripe’s fees. At $3,000 it is $49 + $147 = $196. At $10,000 it is $539.
Idun Blue costs €199 a month (US$199) excl. VAT whatever you sell, with Stripe’s fees on top, just as with Memberful. Below about $3,100 a month in member payments, Memberful is the cheaper of the two. Above it, the 4.9% makes the difference grow every month. At half price, €99 (US$99), the break-even is about $1,000 a month.
Where Memberful is stronger
- Your existing WordPress site. Memberful’s WordPress plugin protects content on the site you already have. With Idun Blue you build the website in Idun.
- Membership details. Group plans, gift purchases, choose-what-you-pay and automated retention discounts are built in.
- Checkout in 15 languages. Memberful lists 15 language translations on every plan.
- No cost before you launch. You pay nothing until you take live payments.
Where Idun Blue does more
No percentage of your income. Memberful takes 4.9% of every charge, for as long as you sell. Idun Blue takes 0%.
Courses, email and community in one account. In Idun Blue the course, the mailing list and the community share one contact record. Broadcasts, sequences and automations react to purchases, finished lessons, quiz results, forms and bookings, without Mailchimp or Kit in between.
The website is included. You build pages, sales pages, a blog and link in bio in Studio, on your own domain. There is no separate site to keep up to date.
Bookings, podcast, events and invoices. Bookings and coaching, a podcast with its own RSS feed and premium episodes, live events with replays and invoices sit in the same account as the membership.
Idun AI drafts, you decide. It writes sales pages, course outlines and welcome sequences from what is already in your account, and nothing goes out until you say yes. You can also connect your own ChatGPT or Claude.
Switch to Idun Blue if
- you would rather pay in euros or kronor than in US dollars, and want Studio, checkout, receipts and invoices in Swedish or English.
- you sell yoga, qigong or stress management in Sweden and want buyers to get a receipt that can be reimbursed through their friskvårdsbidrag right after purchase. Their employer decides.
- you invoice companies or associations and want a Swish QR code on the invoice.
- your Memberful fees have grown past what Idun Blue costs and you want to stop paying 4.9% of every payment.
- you run Memberful plus a website, an email tool and a course tool and want fewer logins.
Common questions
What does Memberful cost?
Memberful's Standard plan costs $49 a month plus a 4.9% transaction fee on every successful charge, and Stripe's processing fees come on top. Enterprise is priced on request. You can set up Memberful in test mode for free and are charged only when you go live. Checked on memberful.com/pricing on 7 October 2026.
Does Memberful take a cut of my sales?
Yes, 4.9% of every successful charge, in addition to the $49 monthly fee and Stripe's fees. Idun Blue takes a 0% platform fee, and you pay only Stripe's fees.
Does Memberful handle VAT?
Memberful can collect tax at checkout, but its help page says it does not file or remit the tax. You do. Idun Blue works the same way: Idun calculates Swedish VAT, EU reverse charge, OSS and export at checkout, and you declare it.
Can I move from Memberful to Idun Blue?
Yes, and we help you. You bring contacts, members and purchases from Memberful's export and import them in Studio, and course progress too when the export includes it.
Keep reading
- FeaturePaymentsPayments go to your own Stripe account. One-off purchases, subscriptions and instalments, with VAT worked out from where each buyer lives.
- FeatureCommunityRooms for conversations, questions and events next to your courses. Give a course its own room and everyone who buys it gets in.
- FeatureCoursesCourses with video, audio and text in modules. Lessons open at your pace, quizzes sit inside the lessons, and participants pick up where they left off.
- Who it is forIdun Blue for membership sitesMembers pay monthly or yearly, and the courses and group stay open to them for as long as they pay.
Thinking about moving from Memberful?
We help you move contacts, members and purchases from your export, and course progress too when the export includes it. You don't have to move everything at once.
The first 100 pay half price, €99/month excl. VAT.
